Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Login with username, password and session length
Home
Forum
Board List
OOTP Reports
WBA Home Page
WBA Expanded Standings
WBA Cup Home Page
S+
Draft
Draft History
Postseason Awards
Real Time Sim Page
Roster Limit Check
Slack Group
WBA Information
Owners List
Join WBA
Constitution
Detailed Financial Report
Financial Brief
Arbitration Salaries Table
Team Salaries Table
Draft Pick Trades
Full WBA Standings
Team Map
WBA Tools
Contracts Compliance Check
Player Positions Check
DFA Status Table
Player Ratings
WBA History
WBA (ABL pre-2130) Index
IBL (2100-2129) Index
WBA Championship Series
Championship Pennants
FSSL Reports
Fast Sim Side League Home Page
FSSL Expanded Standings
Login
Register
World Baseball Association
»
WBA Official Business
»
Constitutional Amendments
»
The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
User Info
Username:
Password:
1 Hour
1 Day
1 Week
1 Month
Forever
Welcome,
Guest
. Please
login
or
register
.
Who's Online
Guests: 14
Hidden: 0
Users: 0
There aren't any users online.
Search
« previous
next »
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Down
Author
Topic: The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades (Read 1273 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Bob_Meteors
Team Owner
Hero Member
Posts: 599
The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
«
on:
April 19, 2020, 08:23:55 PM »
I recently proposed allowing picks up to the 10th round to be traded. In response to the argument that these picks are useless, I have compiled a list of all 6th-10th round picks with over 10.0 career WAR. (note for pitchers I only included pitching WAR, and for batters I only included batting WAR.)
This list only goes up until the 2110 draft because after that, very few players have had long enough careers to reach 10 WAR.
Ryan Hernández
- 2105 Round 9 - 61.98 WAR
Harsendu Dhurvusala
- 2103 Round 10 - 44.39 WAR
Yu-shu Lung
- 2104 Round 6 - 42.22 WAR
Blake Waller
- 2107 Round 6 - 38.77 WAR
Bao-tian Qian
- 2103 Round 7 - 31.38 WAR
Abdeljilill Abedi
- 2104 Round 6 - 30.42 WAR
Christovão Neri
- 2105 Round 7 - 27.53 WAR
Achaius Mainaky
- 2106 Round 7 - 25.61 WAR
Badr bin Hassan
- 2102 Round 6 - 22.33 WAR
Botol Ranho
- 2102 Round 6 - 21.51 WAR
Endres Bäumer
- 2101 Round 6 - 19.38 WAR
Mennad Belqola
- 2104 Round 7 - 18.71 WAR
Tilmão Argolo
- 2101 Round 6 - 18.56 WAR
Jack Joyce
- 2110 Round 10 - 17.82 WAR
Juan Carrasco
- 2104 Round 10 - 15.67 WAR
Ta-heng Chan
- 2104 Round 7 - 15.53 WAR
Bob Poole
- 2104 Round 6 - 15.38 WAR
Abdul-Jabbar Ubaida
- 2109 Round 7 - 15.01 WAR
Daud Khorasani
- 2104 Round 6 - 13.81 WAR
Jyotibhasin Rai
- 2105 Round 6 - 13.58 WAR
Eustachio Clementi
- 2102 Round 8 - 13.27 WAR
Éric Sanchez
- 2110 Round 6 - 13.07 WAR
Brendan St. John
- 2104 Round 10 - 12.57 WAR
Man Chin
- 2101 Round 8 - 12.29 WAR
Xiao-yan Song
- 2102 Round 6 - 11.65 WAR
Danya Yadrov
- 2104 Round 7 - 11.22 WAR
Santos Pina
- 2104 Round 6 - 11.10 WAR
Candrabali Malavika
- 2105 Round 10 - 13.43 WAR
Aranyakumara Yamura
- 2106 Round 7 - 12.33 WAR
Cong Yen
- 2105 Round 7 - 10.66 WAR
Robinson Cordero
- 2106 Round 9 - 10.27 WAR
Sixto Valdéz
- 2101 Round 6 - 10.21 WAR
Wilson Calip
- 2101 Round 6 - 10.21 WAR
Xian-yao Nan
- 2104 Round 6 - 10.18 WAR
Harmage Partha
- 2102 Round 8 - 10.12 WAR
As an interesting side note, here's a list of players in the 11th-20th rounds with over 10.0 career WAR. Potential future amendment??
Ronnie Drew
- 2105 Round 13 - 68.21 WAR
Han-wu Han
- 2103 Round 17 - 55.50 WAR
Itri Jela
- 2104 Round 17 - 50.70 WAR
Thai Ho-Dac
- 2103 Round 11 - 36.81 WAR
Samuel Bravo
- 2103 Round 12 - 35.23 WAR
Janardan Shreerang
- 2103 Round 19 - 31.52 WAR
Dan Harmon
- 2107 Round 15 - 31.00 WAR
Zuleide Rainha
- 2101 Round 13 - 29.35 WAR
Dhrtadhiti Indrani
- 2103 Round 19 - 21.24 WAR
Doan Ba
- 2106 Round 17 - 19.17 WAR
Su-shun Chin
- 2107 Round 13 - 18.56 WAR
Nasih bin Kamil
- 2104 Round 11 - 16.90 WAR
Carlos Granados
- 2106 Round 17 - 15.63 WAR
Sami Kisito
- 2106 Round 14 - 14.54 WAR
Freddi Uhlirz
- 2110 Round 14 - 13.39 WAR
Tsadik Shukrani
- 2102 Round 11 - 12.74 WAR
Pedro Gil
- 2101 Round 14 - 11.96 WAR
Arvinder Sivasubramanian
- 2106 Round 14 - 11.41 WAR
You-liang Ai
- 2106 Round 12 - 10.88 WAR
From 2101 to 2110, 35 players drafted in rounds 6-10 reached 10 career WAR. There were a total of 1000 picks in those rounds during that time period (5 rounds * 10 picks per round * 2 league drafts * 10 years), suggesting that these picks have a ~3.5% chance of developing into a highly valuable player. Representing a "lottery card" with value, they should, therefore, be tradeable.
Logged
Manager:
Brisbane Bandits 2107-2108
Melbourne Meteors 2108-
2108 WBA Champions
2142 WBA Champions
claphamsa
Former Owner
Sr. Member
Posts: 384
Re: The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
«
Reply #1 on:
April 19, 2020, 08:25:47 PM »
your argument is talent variation is too high in the daft and should be decreased....Ill buy that.
Logged
claphamsa
Former Owner
Sr. Member
Posts: 384
Re: The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
«
Reply #2 on:
April 19, 2020, 08:27:07 PM »
also you have no control...what about higher rounds? 14 cases (I didn't count) of players getting blessings from the talent fairy...doesn't mean these players arent dog shit when drafted
Logged
Huckleberry
Administrator
Hero Member
Posts: 3331
Re: The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
«
Reply #3 on:
April 19, 2020, 08:50:50 PM »
I will say that I'm also not in favor still, but this was an outstanding job of research.
While it pains me in my core to admit it, I agree with clap. I would lean more toward lowering the talent change randomness setting instead.
Logged
Bob_Meteors
Team Owner
Hero Member
Posts: 599
Re: The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
«
Reply #4 on:
April 20, 2020, 10:22:05 PM »
In response to requests for current distributions of draft location among 4+ star potential players:
SP
Alfredo Cavazos
was drafted in the 7th round of the 2115 ABL draft and is now 4OV/4.5POT.
SP
Wen-zhong Cheng
was drafted in the 6th round of the 2114 IBL draft and is now 4OV/4POT.
SP
Anupradana Koushika
was drafted in the 14th round of the 2118 IBL draft and is now 2.5OV/4POT.
SP
Ismael Muñóz
was drafted in the 6th round of the 2116 ABL draft and is now 3OV/4POT.
CL
Carlos Piña
was drafted in the 6th round of the 2116 ABL draft and is now 4OV/4POT.
SS
Mitch Reddick
was drafted in the 12th round of the 2119 IBL draft and is now 3OV/4POT.
3B
Weiner Uhlirz
was drafted in the 12th round of the 2116 IBL draft and is now 4OV/4POT.
Overall, of the 113 players with 4+ potential, 7 of them were drafted later than the 5th round. This is not the same percentage as the odds of getting a good player in those later rounds, but furthers the theory that these picks represent lottery tickets with a small but not insignificant chance of developing into valuable players.
Logged
Manager:
Brisbane Bandits 2107-2108
Melbourne Meteors 2108-
2108 WBA Champions
2142 WBA Champions
Print
Pages: [
1
]
Go Up
« previous
next »
World Baseball Association
»
WBA Official Business
»
Constitutional Amendments
»
The Case for Allowing Later Draft Pick Trades
Latest OOTP News
SP Cvetkovic Signs with Black Forest
WBA Headline News: Spring Training Begins
SimplePortal 2.3.7 © 2008-2024, SimplePortal